Every app here charges $0 commission on stock and ETF trades, so the fee moved to idle cash.
By Michael Hewitt, Founder & Editor-in-Chief. Updated September 29, 2026.
The commission went to zero years ago, so every app here is "free," and the real fee moved somewhere harder to see: what the app pays on cash you have not invested yet. On a beginner's idle $2,000, the difference between 0% and 3.6% is about $72 a year, which is worth more than any charting feature. Robinhood's 3.6% requires Gold at $5 a month, which eats $60 of that $72; Fidelity pays about 3.4% with no subscription. Robinhood still ranks first because Gold also lifts its IRA match from 1% to 3%, enough to cover the fee on a $3,000 contribution.
Robinhood is first because Gold, at $5 a month, pays for itself through retirement saving: it lifts the IRA match from 1% to 3%, and 2% of a $3,000 contribution is $60, a year of Gold. Anything past that, plus 3.6% on idle cash, is ahead of the fee.
Two conditions apply: keep Gold for a year and leave the matched money in the IRA for five. Treat it as retirement money, not a bonus.
$0 commissions on stocks, ETFs, options and crypto; fractional shares from $1.
24-hour trading on 900+ stocks and ETFs, plus futures and index options.
Not for: anyone who wants mutual funds, bonds, a 529 plan or deep fundamental research.
Best for Retirement and Idle Cash: Fidelity
Fidelity is for anyone who will not pay a subscription. Idle cash sits in SPAXX, the default core position, which yielded about 3.4% in late September 2026: about $68 a year on $2,000, against $12 at Robinhood after Gold's $60.
It offers every account a household needs, including 401(k), 529 and HSA, research from 20+ providers, and four index funds with a zero expense ratio.
$0 commissions on stocks and ETFs; options cost $0.65 a contract.
No account minimums or maintenance fees, and no payment for order flow.
Not for: a first-timer who wants the simplest app. Fidelity is built for breadth, and the menus show it.
Best for Research: Charles Schwab
Schwab is for the investor who wants to study a position before buying it. Its thinkorswim platform, inherited from TD Ameritrade, brings advanced charting, options analytics and paper trading to desktop, web and mobile, and research from Morningstar, Argus and MarketEdge is free. It also has 300+ branches and 24/7 phone support.
Not for: a beginner who wants one simple screen. thinkorswim has a steep learning curve.
For beginners: SoFi Invest
SoFi suits a first account for someone who wants banking, investing and a planner in one app. It links to SoFi Checking, Savings and Credit Card, includes access to a credentialed SoFi financial planner, and matches IRA contributions and rollovers at 1% with no subscription.
The sign-up offer is up to $1,000 in stock when you fund $50 or more; "up to" describes the best case.
$0 commissions on stocks and ETFs; fractional shares from $5.
Automated portfolios carry a 0.25% annual advisory fee, and no tax-loss harvesting.
Not for: anyone who wants research depth or will not use SoFi's banking. Without the bundle it is a plain brokerage with no mutual funds.
Best for Active Traders: Webull
Webull is for the trader who wants pro-grade charts without paying for a platform. Level 2 Nasdaq TotalView quotes are free, options carry no per-contract fee (Fidelity and Schwab charge $0.65), and 24-hour weekday trading covers select stocks and ETFs. Paper trading, crypto, and Traditional, Roth and Rollover IRAs are included.
Not for: a buy-and-hold investor who wants mutual funds in a taxable account, since Webull offers them only in IRAs. Fundamental research also trails Fidelity and Schwab.
Key Takeaways
When trades carry $0 commission, the fee that matters is what idle cash earns: 0% versus 3.6% on a beginner's $2,000 is about $72 a year.
Robinhood is #1 because Gold ($5 a month) pays 3.6% on cash and lifts the IRA match from 1% to 3%, which covers the fee on a $3,000 contribution if you keep Gold a year and leave the match in for five.
Fidelity (#2) pays about 3.4% on cash with no subscription, which beats Gold for anyone not funding a Robinhood IRA and holding less than roughly $30,000 in cash.
Schwab wins on research, SoFi on bundled banking for beginners, and Webull on free Level 2 quotes and no per-contract options fee.