CarShield Review
The biggest VSC marketer, taking cars to 300K miles, with a 2024 FTC settlement buyers must know about. Independent CarShield review: 3.4/5 for auto warranty.
About CarShield
The biggest VSC marketer, taking cars to 300K miles, with a 2024 FTC settlement buyers must know about. CarShield is offered by NRRM, LLC (CarShield); administered by American Auto Shield and currently holds an average rating of 3.4 out of 5 across 53,000 user reviews. It falls into the Auto Warranty category and tends to be the strongest fit for high-mileage vehicles other providers reject, eyes open on the record.
Editorial grade: C+ (composite score 62/100).
Highlights
- Accepts vehicles up to 300,000 miles, among the highest limits in the industry
- Month-to-month contracts from ~$99/mo with $0-deductible options
- Six tiers from powertrain (Silver) to exclusionary (Diamond), plus motorcycle/ATV
What we like
- High-mileage and older vehicles that other brands decline
- Flexible month-to-month terms you can cancel anytime
- Direct payment to any ASE-certified shop via the administrator
Where it falls short
- July 2024 FTC settlement: $10M over deceptive advertising and telemarketing; $9.6M in refunds mailed to 168,000+ customers in Dec 2025
- CarShield is a marketer, not the administrator: claims decisions rest with American Auto Shield
- BBB customer score ~2.9/5 with a documented complaint pattern; not sold in California
Fees, minimums, and rates
Monthly fee: ~$99-$170/mo; deductibles $0-$250. Minimum to open: 30-day + 1,000-mile waiting period. Rates and promotional offers change often, so we re-verify every listed number on a rolling schedule and stamp the review with the date of the most recent check.
How we reviewed it
For this review of CarShield, our editors funded an account, walked through the full onboarding flow, and compared the experience to the other products in the Auto Warranty shortlist. Scores are not influenced by affiliate relationships — partners cannot pay for better rankings, and our rubric is the same for every brand.
Similar products to compare
- GEICO Auto Insurance review
- Progressive Auto Insurance review
- State Farm Auto Insurance review
- USAA Auto Insurance review
Read our full editorial methodology and advertiser disclosure for more on how we fund our testing and why that matters for the reviews you read here.